Pub Theology 10/29/24 -- Finding meaning, making meaning

Peter Trumbore • October 28, 2024

So what is the meaning of life anyway? And no, this is not a reference to the Monty Python movie, so let's all just move along shall we? But before we do, let me recommend the film to you. It's great.


I gave a little mention to this topic last week, and there was an immediate response from one of our regular participants that makes me think there's something for us to talk about here. I had said something about the idea of "finding"meaning in our lives, but our regular straight up pounced on the notion, arguing instead that we should talk about "making" meaning instead. So let's do both!


The idea for the topic came up a couple of weeks ago when I ran across this article at The Atlantic website: "The Meaning of Life is Surprisingly Simple," in which the author. Arthur Brooks, reminded us that those people who believe they know their life's meaning enjoy greater well-being than those who don't. But he acknowledged that it's a lucky few who figure it out early. For the rest of us, he says, there's work to be done. And the search can be difficult and frustrating: "Philosophy is often unhelpful, offering abstract ideas such as Aristotle’s human function or Kant’s “highest good” that are hard to comprehend, let alone put into action." The easiest response, then, may just be to throw up our hands and conclude that the meaning of life is unknowable, at least to us.


This would be a mistake, though, and Brooks offers the reader a suggestion: Make the quest manageable by breaking it down into what he says are three easily digestible steps. These start with an understanding that we can think about finding meaning by assessing our life along the following dimensions. First is coherence, or how events in your life fit together. "This is an understanding that things happen in your life for a reason. That doesn’t necessarily mean you can fit new developments into your narrative the moment they happen, but you usually are able to do so afterward, so you have faith that you eventually will." Second is purpose, or the existence of goals and aims. "This is the belief that you are alive in order to do something. Think of purpose as your personal mission statement ..." And third is significance, or the sense that your life matters. Together, he describes these as macronutrients: "the elements that we need for a balanced and healthy sense of meaning in life."


With the in mind, let's take a look at Brooks' digestible steps toward figuring out meaning.


Step 1 -- Check your diet. If you have a sense that your life lacks meaning, then take a look at your "macronutrient balance" and ask yourself the following questions:

  • Do you feel out of control, tossed about in life without rhyme or reason? You might need a better sense of coherence.
  • Do you lack big plans or dreams or ideas about your future that excite you? If not, that's a purpose issue.
  • Do you feel like it wouldn't matter if you just disappeared, that the world would be no better off with or without you? That's significance.


Step 2 -- Search in the forest. If you find you have a deficit in one of the above, go look for it in a productive way. The good news for us Pub Theologians is that we may have an already existing spiritual or philosophical outlook that can guide us, like prayer, or meditation, or even therapy. The key, though, is to approach the search the way you would anything that's important to you, by being intentional and doing the work.


Step 3 -- Make sure you don't search too hard. Here Brooks makes the point that your quest for meaning becomes counterproductive if it gets in the way of your happiness: "If you feel lost in your search for meaning, cut yourself some slack and go back to the basics."


All of this, Brooks acknowledges, stems from the starting assumption that life does in fact have meaning. That's a perspective that not all of us may share, and so that is going to be our starting point for our discussion this week. So, first, do you think that your life has meaning? Even if you're not sure what that might be? Then second, what do you make of the distinction between "finding" meaning and "making" meaning in our lives? Are those really different ideas? Finally, what do you make of Brooks' overall argument here? Do the concepts of coherence, purpose, and significance resonate with you? And do you think Brooks' three simple steps are a a good way to figure it all out?


We'll talk all about it in our conversation this Tuesday evening, Oct. 29, The discussion starts at 7pm at Casa Real in downtown Oxford.

By Peter Trumbore • November 16, 2026
This is a time of year that is characterized by change. The environment around us is in a state of flux. The time has changed. The weather is changing. We're transitioning into the holidays, and for those of us who worship in churches with a liturgical tradition, the season of Advent is right around the corner, a time of preparation before the Nativity. In other words, we're moving on to the next thing. Even if we don't know what that next thing might be. For some of us, this idea of moving on has particular relevance as retirements loom and career changes (whether wanted or not) are in view. Sometimes moving on is the consequence of accomplishment. You've had a big task or project that you may have dedicated much of your time, energy, even life to. So how do you move on after you achieve something you have been dedicated to accomplishing? Is moving on from success different that moving on after disappointment? There's lots of context we can bring to the table here. As suggested by the above, what does this idea of moving on mean in terms of life goals or in terms of life-changing events? How do we redefine our efforts, our dreams, and ourselves in those situations? What does it take to "move on?" Does the journey start with just one step? What happens when we are "shoved" instead of taking that step willingly? What happens when we are physically or emotionally unable to take that step? What happens when we are content with where we are, is change required? Is change inevitable? On the face of it, this week's topic doesn't have a lot of theology attached to the pub part. But the way we think about our answers to the questions posed may be definitely faith-based. How do we create/leverage/trust/have faith in a relationship with God in these moments? How does God help us to persevere in these moments? What is God's role in these moments occurring? Join us for the conversation this Tuesday, Nov. 17, starting at 7pm at Irish Tavern in downtown Lake Orion.
By Andrew Guffey • November 15, 2026
This Sunday, all are welcome to join us for a morning of worship and fellowship. Whether you are with us in the sanctuary or joining from afar, your presence strengthens our community. Our service is at 9:30 a.m. We warmly welcome those who cannot attend in person to join us via our live stream.
By Andrew Guffey • November 14, 2026
Courage to Live at the Limit of Us
By Peter Trumbore • November 9, 2026
First, and before anyone panics and despite first appearances, this is not a political topic. It just happens to stem from the words of a political figure. On Sunday evening, President Trump gave an extraordinary interview to the CBS program "60 Minutes." This interview came just days after his party suffered historic losses in midterm elections, and while the discussion did touch on that, and other issues, towards the end it swerved into an unexpected lane. Correspondent Ross Douthat, who while a writer at The New York Times wrote often about the intersection of faith and public policy (often from a conservative Roman Catholic perspective), asked the president whether he could forgive his political enemies if that was what it took to enter heaven. Trump, who described himself as "a religious person," nevertheless balked at the answer. Douthat pressed: "Mr. President, you have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me that before the judgment throne of God, you couldn't find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that's been given to you?" Trump responded: "Can I be honest? I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies, and I always will." To put it bluntly, Trump suggested he would rather hold onto his grudges and go to hell than forgive his enemies. Leaving politics out of it, how do you respond to this? How do you square this with your own experience? In order for us to be forgiven, must we forgive everyone we believe has wronged us? As Christians, or as people of faith more generally, do we have a responsibility to forgive others? Are there things for us that cannot be forgiven, even at the cost of our own salvation? Join us for the conversation tomorrow evening, Tuesday, Nov. 10, starting at 7pm at Irish Tavern in downtown Lake Orion.
By Andrew Guffey • November 8, 2026
This Sunday, all are welcome to join us for a morning of worship and fellowship. Whether you are with us in the sanctuary or joining from afar, your presence strengthens our community. Our service is at 9:30 a.m. We warmly welcome those who cannot attend in person to join us via our live stream.
By Andrew Guffey • November 1, 2026
This Sunday, all are welcome to join us for a morning of worship and fellowship. Whether you are with us in the sanctuary or joining from afar, your presence strengthens our community. Our service is at 9:30 a.m. We warmly welcome those who cannot attend in person to join us via our live stream.
By Peter Trumbore • October 26, 2026
"From ghoulies and ghosties, long-leggedy beasties, and things that go bump in the night, Good Lord deliver us!" This very old folk prayer, which has been tied to both Scotland and Cornwall, used to hang on the wall of my childhood home, and it often comes to mind for me at this time of year. A little trivia -- the first known publication of this prayer was in 1926 in a volume titled "The Cornish and West Country Litany," but it is thought to be far older. That it can be traced to regions of the United Kingdom that are quite distant from one another may be a testament to its antiquity. Anyway, we're right up to the climax of what some call "spooky season," the weeks from the end of summer up until Halloween, which this year falls on Saturday. Apparently this idea of "spooky season" is a relatively recent development, becoming popular on the internet as a way to talk about stretching the adult of fun of Halloween from a single day of dress-up shenanigans to something akin to the more well-established holiday season we're now rocketing toward. This is a far cry from what I recall growing up, where more than a few of the local churches in our area very actively sought to discourage observance of Halloween, labeling it a pagan celebration of witchcraft, devilry, and superstition that was incompatible with being a good Christian. Of course that didn't really dissuade anyone. But with the holiday just a few days away, I thought this would be a good opportunity for us to talk about the nature of spooky stuff, ghoulies and ghosties, and other such things. So tell us, what do you love about Halloween? How do you mark it? Does anything give you pause? What do you think about this claim that you can't be a Christian and still participate in or enjoy Halloween? Finally, what do you make of that old Scots and Cornish prayer? What real fears do you think it reflects? And what might a modern version look like? Join us for the conversation tomorrow evening, Tuesday Oct. 27 starting at 7pm at Irish Tavern in downtown Lake Orion.
By Andrew Guffey • October 25, 2026
This Sunday, all are welcome to join us for a morning of worship and fellowship. Whether you are with us in the sanctuary or joining from afar, your presence strengthens our community. Our service is at 9:30 a.m. We warmly welcome those who cannot attend in person to join us via our live stream.
By Andrew Guffey • October 18, 2026
This Sunday, all are welcome to join us for a morning of worship and fellowship. Whether you are with us in the sanctuary or joining from afar, your presence strengthens our community. Our service is at 9:30 a.m. We warmly welcome those who cannot attend in person to join us via our live stream.
By Peter Trumbore • October 13, 2026
Some weeks inspiration hits and we stumble onto a single topic that has enough going for it that our Tuesday evening conversation revolves around it entirely. Some weeks, like this one, we take a different approach. Tonight, rather than chew on one big idea, we've got a couple of interesting, but generally unrelated questions to animate our discussion. We'll take them on one at a time, in no particular order, and see what develops. Nine years ago New Yorker cartoonist David Sipress drew a cartoon with this caption: "My desire to be well-informed is currently at odds with my desire to remain sane.” Do you experience this tension in your own life, and if so, how do you deal with it? Are you more interested in buying things, or experiencing things? How far will you go to experience something for the first time? What is an example of that? Are you a thrill seeker? An adventure traveler? Something else? Lutheran pastor and writer Nadia Bola-Weber said this: "People don't leave Christianity because they stop believing in the teachings of Jesus. People leave Christianity because they believe in the teachings of Jesus so much, they can't stomach being part of an institution that claims to be about that and clearly isn't." What is your take on this? Do you agree with her? Why or why not? Podcaster Joe Rogan: "Jesus was born out of a virgin mother. What's more virgin than a computer? If Jesus does return, you don't think he could return as Artificial Intelligence? AI could absolutely return as Jesus." OK, is he off his rocker, or do you think he might be on to something? If all else fails, what's on your mind this week?  Join us for the conversation this evening, Tuesday Oct. 13 starting at 7pm at Irish Tavern in downtown Lake Orion.